February 26, 2006

A glorious Aida


Reviews Written by

So far is the most rewarding Aida I have heard (and I heard Karajan's, Muti's and one of Callas' with R Tucker). Everything from conducting which is rock-solid and beautifully blended to the choir and trumpets in the march is what this opera should be about.

First and foremost is the amazing Corelli who does one of his landmark characters here. He is heroic and gentle in the same amount and could pull you up from the chair or can bring tears from your eyes in the final duet. And you must be really malintended to say that his diminuendo (amazing to almost unbelievable) is a fake. And the way it serves the moment is the mark of an outstanding artist.

And yet you can't say that this set should be called Radames. Nilsson is powerfull. Great voice sometimes a little to great for my taste but on the other hand I can't see many sopranos standing next to Corelli in the kind of shape he shows here. A very real and believable Aida. The duos with Corelli are so full of emotion, intensity and glorious voice you couldn't wish for more. Very good indeed.

Sereni is the big surprise. Even if he doesn't have the greatest of baritone voices he sounds passionate and defines his character in great and very beautiful detail. A real accomplishment.

And don't make any mistakes. Grace Bumbry comes up with an Amneris that is everything you expect her to be. You can feel her pain her deep conflict with Aida, her love for Radames all in beautiful singing.

The high priest and the choir do a very fine job completing a great Aida. It doesn't have any weak moments. It is full instead of many great ones. It is impossible to go wrong with this version of this opera.

A final mention for Mehta and his Roma opera orchestra. They sound gorgiously. I didn't feel sorry at any point missing the details of Karajan or Muti. They play with passion and strength giving the singers a prolific and inspiring sound environment. Their orchestral parts come very well as equals of great moments the singers bring.

This is an Aida that proudly stands among the Aida's that make the rules in the recording history. One of the very heavy measures for the others recordings.

No comments: