This article roots from a completely different source than usual. It is not caused by a listening experience, yet rather a reading experience. The Dean of science journals,
Nature, has in its issue from November 30th, a very interesting brief communication on the wood that Stradivarius and Guarneri del Gesu used to build their violins. It is the beginning of a salutary scientific look into the mysteries of some of the greatest creations of humankind. To give you a taste of this work let me quote the authors on the key aspects. They motivate their research as such: "Whether or not the great Italian violin-makers used wood that had been chemically processed in order to preserve it and enhance the instrument’s sound quality has long been a contentious issue1,2." Then, they go and briefly describe the methods they used: "Here we use nuclear magnetic resonance and infrared spectroscopy to analyze organic matter in wood taken from antique instruments made by Stradivari and Guarneri del Gesu." Their results are intriguing: "Our results indicate that the wood used by the masters could indeed have been chemically treated, a technique that may inspire an approach to violin making that is more chemistry-based." You can read the details and the actual data in the article.
For those of you that are not completely familiar with the subject of the paper I will try to give you a flavor of these exquisite instruments. Both violin makers families, as more than just one member was in this business, built their instruments in the second half of the seventeen and the first decades of the eighteen centuries. Both learned the art of violin making from Nicolo Amati yet, most importantly, both tried to create better instruments. And while they did that they created instruments with a very particular sound. At least for me the Guarneri is unsurpassed in the way it produces the high end of the spectrum. Not only is it full bodied and tonally perfect but is also sweet and almost form a different world. Here I definitely prefer it over Stradivari. At the middle of the spectrum Stradivari comes ahead. The amount of tone and its beauty are above any other instrument. It is rich and manages to bring out all the saps of the earth. Don't get me wrong, Guarneri is close and both are far away from any competition. It is just that here Stradivari reaches the absolute. At the lower end of the spectrum it is extremely difficult to set them apart and is just a matter of the hands they're in and your personal preferences. Sometimes I hear the Guarneri a little more "polished" and more "human" if you want. Nonetheless the Stradivari makes up in power and transparency. It is a tie as it is the whole "competition". It is an immense pleasure to listen to any of them as often as you have the chance.
Allow me to point to two cds that can illustrate best the amazing qualities of these violins. I picked one for each, both in the hands of favorite violinists: Nathan Milstein and Ruggiero Ricci. Nathan was playing on a Stradivari and in my view he is a perfect example of what can be made out of such a great instrument. His tone is sublime and his artistry makes the instrument live the most accomplished life. One of his great recordings is described in extenso
here and you can hardly find a better illustration for the instrument (the quality of the recording is gorgeous).
Ricci on the other hand played a Guarneri and him too makes an almost perfect case for what this instrument can do. Below you have details on one of the reissues of some of his recordings in impeccable sound. It doesn't get any better than this. Give them a try and I am pretty sure one question that will pop out is: How could those guys build such wonders? I really hope that the research we are talking about here will go on and will give us some insights in an old and, obviously, extremely efficient technique, the geniuses of the men aside.
And because they form a special case I will also mention here the Alban Berg Quartet. One of the very special things about them is that all the instruments are Stradivari. The result is obvious on the spot as the tonal quality of the quartet is one of their landmarks. All over their recordings their artistry is helped hugely by their beautiful instruments. Clearly that's the case in their recording of
Beethoven's String Quartets, one of the great victories of the recorded music.
For those of you that are not completely familiar with the subject of the paper I will try to give you a flavor of these exquisite instruments. Both violin makers families, as more than just one member was in this business, built their instruments in the second half of the seventeen and the first decades of the eighteen centuries. Both learned the art of violin making from Nicolo Amati yet, most importantly, both tried to create better instruments. And while they did that they created instruments with a very particular sound. At least for me the Guarneri is unsurpassed in the way it produces the high end of the spectrum. Not only is it full bodied and tonally perfect but is also sweet and almost form a different world. Here I definitely prefer it over Stradivari. At the middle of the spectrum Stradivari comes ahead. The amount of tone and its beauty are above any other instrument. It is rich and manages to bring out all the saps of the earth. Don't get me wrong, Guarneri is close and both are far away from any competition. It is just that here Stradivari reaches the absolute. At the lower end of the spectrum it is extremely difficult to set them apart and is just a matter of the hands they're in and your personal preferences. Sometimes I hear the Guarneri a little more "polished" and more "human" if you want. Nonetheless the Stradivari makes up in power and transparency. It is a tie as it is the whole "competition". It is an immense pleasure to listen to any of them as often as you have the chance.
Allow me to point to two cds that can illustrate best the amazing qualities of these violins. I picked one for each, both in the hands of favorite violinists: Nathan Milstein and Ruggiero Ricci. Nathan was playing on a Stradivari and in my view he is a perfect example of what can be made out of such a great instrument. His tone is sublime and his artistry makes the instrument live the most accomplished life. One of his great recordings is described in extenso here and you can hardly find a better illustration for the instrument (the quality of the recording is gorgeous).
Ricci on the other hand played a Guarneri and him too makes an almost perfect case for what this instrument can do. Below you have details on one of the reissues of some of his recordings in impeccable sound. It doesn't get any better than this. Give them a try and I am pretty sure one question that will pop out is: How could those guys build such wonders? I really hope that the research we are talking about here will go on and will give us some insights in an old and, obviously, extremely efficient technique, the geniuses of the men aside.
And because they form a special case I will also mention here the Alban Berg Quartet. One of the very special things about them is that all the instruments are Stradivari. The result is obvious on the spot as the tonal quality of the quartet is one of their landmarks. All over their recordings their artistry is helped hugely by their beautiful instruments. Clearly that's the case in their recording of Beethoven's String Quartets, one of the great victories of the recorded music.
